Six Nations: England player evaluations following disappointment in Paris
England’s most disappointing Six Nations in terms of outcomes was solidified with their 48-46 loss to France in Paris.
Although it marked their fourth consecutive defeat, it was England’s most effective offensive performance of the tournament, leaving supporters eager for more.
– Hamilton: France, England conclude tournament with excitement, but uncertainties linger
– Six Nations: France retain championship after thrilling, unpredictable tournament
Below are ESPN’s player evaluations following the exhilarating match at Stade de France.
1. Ellis Genge – 8
Played with determination and was tireless with the ball. However, his yellow card for collapsing the maul proved costly for England, as France scored twice during his absence.
2. Jamie George – 7.5
Effectively managed the lineout, contributing to England’s notable success in set-pieces. While he did not make a significant impact elsewhere, he performed his role competently.
3. Joe Heyes – 8
Helped secure a robust scrum and was a constant threat for France at the breakdown. He managed to disrupt Antoine Dupont on a few occasions, aiding England’s efforts. Completed 12 tackles.
4. Maro Itoje – 8.5
A true captain’s performance. Although he appeared fatigued midway through the second half, he continued to battle. Made several crucial turnovers at important moments.
5. Alex Coles – 7
Served as a strong complement to Itoje once more and was effective in the maul. It was unfortunate that he had to leave the field early.
6. Ollie Chessum – 9
The try-scoring powerhouse! Brought essential physicality to England’s pack and utilized his strength effectively. The two tries were a well-deserved reward.
7. Guy Pepper – 7
Solid defensively and allowed Chessum and Earl to excel. He is evolving into a dependable Test player and solidifying his place in the starting lineup.
8. Ben Earl – 8
England’s standout player of the tournament, delivering another impressive performance. He made sixteen carries despite sustaining a head injury that temporarily sidelined him.
9. Ben Spencer – 9
Quickly got England’s attack flowing from the outset, clearly demonstrating the intent to increase the pace of play. Also displayed a strong kicking game.
10. Fin Smith – 7.5
A mixed performance for the young fly-half, but he will gain valuable experience from this match. Although he missed a couple of key kicks, his conversion-turned-drop-goal was executed excellently.
11. Cadan Murley – 8
Consistently sought opportunities and was rewarded with a try. He was dynamic with the ball and consistently performed well for England.
12. Seb Atkinson – 7
Another valuable learning experience in the challenging environment of Stade de France, he carried effectively and performed solidly overall. He is certainly a player England can rely on.
13. Tommy Freeman – 8
Extremely powerful when he gets going with the ball, he created opportunities on the flanks, raising questions about the centre experiment’s effectiveness. Nonetheless, he will take significant lessons from the campaign and has emerged as a top-tier player.
14. Tom Roebuck – 7
He is not the first and will not be the last to face challenges against France’s edge, particularly Louis Bielle-Biarrey. Still, he was solid overall, contributing with a few good carries.
15. Elliot Daly – 7.5
Started with positive intent, and his kicks through the line set a strong tone for England, but he did not have a major impact beyond that. He provides valuable experience for a younger England backline.
Replacements:
16. Luke Cowan-Dickie: 7
17. Bevan Rodd: 7.5
18. Trevor Davison: n/a
19. Chandler Cunningham-South: n/a
20. Sam Underhill: 7
21. Henry Pollock: 7.5
22. Jack van Poortvliet: 7
23. Marcus Smith: 8
